I think that does give more of a feel of "where you're at." I do hear you about not knowing for sure how you'll use something you haven't yet had. That is one of the hard parts about boat shopping!
I don't fish, so take this with a grain of salt in case your type of fishing precludes it, but.... I'm kind of hearing "Cruiser" vs. "Angler." The reason I say that is that if you are typically alone, or maybe with one other person, perhaps the Cruiser (shorter) cockpit is adequate. In return for giving up that space, you get a bigger dinette (nice place to sit and watch the world go by as you munch, write, read, or what have you), and a bigger galley. Of course we're talking "bigger" in comparison, as they are still compact. But it definitely has a "little cabin on the water" feeling. Sounds like you might like to try that for a change.
Both models have the berth, so there is nothing to decide on that way.
I like having the solid cabin wall (aft) because it cuts down on engine noise, and also gives you a way to lock up the cabin - not thief-proof but better than canvas. You can latch the door open for easy passage back and forth (just duck if you are tall!)
If you like to be warm/out of the weather, then the larger cabin on the Cruiser gives you more "inside space" -- yet with windows all around so you can see out. You can heat that space too. You can get a similar effect with a good camperback (canvas enclosure) on the cockpit of an Angler, but then I would think that might be in the way for fishing? That's what made me think Cruiser: Cabin for warm/sheltered/domestic stuff, and then an open cockpit for fishing (or perhaps with a bimini you can relatively quickly deploy and retract).
The Cruiser gives the chance of two separate sleeping spaces in the cabin, if that ever matters to you (fishing buddies, etc.).
The one place the Cruiser cabin falls short, for me, is in the area of "real" and comfortable seating. As built, there is a pretty minimal helm seat (think of your everyday basic fold-down-back helm seat you'd have in a fishing boat), and then two "straight board and square cushion" type dinette seats. They are perfectly usable, but just not what I'd have in my dream boat. My back is not square

If one didn't need the dinette to fold down into a berth, then perhaps one could put in slightly more comfortable/supportive seats on top of the seat boxes. There is also the cockpit, where you could put a loungy chair, and this is what made the Angler look tempting to me: I had visions of a really good camperback, and then the larger cockpit being my "living room" with something like a LaFuma chaise type chair. That would be a tight fit in the Cruiser cockpit I think (not that I may not try

) I have had two "upright" comfy outdoor chairs in the cockpit of the Cruiser (along with everything else). They fit, but it's a bit tight is all (of course you can often go ashore to sit).
Since you are in California, you're near the home of Pacific Trailers, which are under some C-Dorys. I have always thought they looked very nice, and would be my choice if I were buying a trailer from scratch. (I bought a used C-Dory, so it came with a trailer.)
I don't know how soon you are going to order, or what your traveling options are, but the Seattle Boat Show always attracts a gang of C-Brats, and I believe there would be 22's there to look at (but I would check ahead as they may not have all models there). Another option is to contact a Brat in your area and see if you can get aboard to check one out in person (there is a Brat map link at the top of the page).