thataway":3410oklw said:
As always Roger's posts are right on. Even though the current 22 is my 4th C Dory, and my second 22, I used the boat "as is" for several years, before making improvements of any substantial nature. This included over 2 months on the water and living on the boat. As Roger says, things which seem like a good idea at first--may change with the test of time….
I do hear you both on that. And I have "saved" many things for doing when I have lived on the boat longer than 5 weeks. (Camper back, chartplotter, radar, hydraulic steering, autopilot, new water tank... the list goes on.)
thataway":3410oklw said:
-you took out the 22 gallon water tank--weight full is somewhere near 170 lbs--more than the weight of the battery.
Slight correction though: My stock tank was about 17.5 gallons, and it's removed only because it sprung a leak. But I now carry three 6-gallon jugs in the same locker, for 18 gallons, so it's the same weight. With those chock full, I still list pretty good to starboard. With my 270 lb. co-pilot (friend who was with me on Powell), full tanks, and the port locker that may get the batteries full of tools and gear (i.e. similar weight to the proposed batteries), I still only listed very very slightly to port, and it was easily correctable with the trim tabs. Two Group 31 "plumpies" (125 aH) would be around 140# (plus a bit more for cables etc.) So it seems that it might be a good option, weight-wise. I cannot add a second house battery to the lazarette regardless, for space reasons (not to mention weight).
I don't mind a slight list, and I agree with you that some moveable "trimming" ballast is always a good idea; but my boat lists more than slightly to starboard, I can't trim it away, and I would like to improve that. If I can do it while also doing something else I want (larger house bank plus charging capability), then I'm going to consider it (what I'm doing now).
From past boats I know that just about no matter how long I wait to do things, or how much I think or plan, there will be "Oh, should have done it THAT way" or "I don't even USE this, wish I had not bothered" moments as I use the boat more. So to me it's about finding the balance between just doing nothing (i.e. going to Powell this year, with all the same issues I made notes on last year), vs. doing too much (why I am leaving dozens of things "for later").
I don't mind when people question though, as I do the same thing. I mean, if someone posted that they were going to put in a 50-gallon water tank, but only used the boat evenings after work for sitting at the dock and having cocktails, I might question if they really wanted to go that route. And that sort of re-evaluating assumptions can be very useful. There are so many experienced hands here :thup
Sunbeam