Thoughts on the 2010 market and Boat Show season

Matt Gurnsey

New member
Saw this on another site, and found it interesting:

According to Thom Dammrich, president of the NMMA, only 135,000 new boats of all sizes were sold at retail this year, down from over 400,000 just a few years ago. Of the 135,000 sales, about 82,000 were “non-current” inventory, which means that they did not have 2009 HIN numbers on their transoms. All of this means that dedicated boaters are still buying in the middle of the Great Recession, they are getting great deals on merchandise, and inventory is heading back to a more normal balance. Our own spot checking around the country with dealers indicates that in many sought-after brands, you may not be able to find the specific model you want in dealer inventory and it will have to be ordered. (Non-current models are often great deals.)

Only 53,000 new boats of all sizes were shipped to boat dealers this year, which is about 17% of what was shipped 3-4 years ago.

Soundings Trade Only industry magazine recently published the results of an RBC Capital Markets survey of boat dealers. This study indicates that dealers are in far better positions, generally, this year than they were in the fall of 2008, when the financial world almost melted down. According to the survey, fewer than 7% of the dealers responding stated that they had “way too much inventory,” as compared with 16% a year ago.

Another 21% of the dealers said they still "had too much", down from 34% a year ago. Interestingly, 17% of the dealers said that their inventory levels were now “way too low.” 35% of the dealers said that their inventories are currently “about right.” That means half feel they are too low or about right.

So, roughly speaking, 1/3 of the dealers are still over-stocked, 1/3 are under stocked, and 1/3 think their inventories are about right.

Still a Buyers Market

NMMA President Dammrich and other industry observers are not forecasting large sales gains in 2010, and most prudent industry veterans are banking on sales of about 135,000 to 150,000 in 2010. Most of these sales are for very small boats. Only about 33% of all boat sales are for units 21’ or larger, which means last year only about 45,000 boats 21’ or larger were sold new.

With industry-wide production at just 53,000 units this year and factories closed for much of the year, or on skeleton staffs, most observers are predicting only a modest increase in boat production for 2010 to further improve the balance of inventory in the field.

All of this means that for the short run at least, boat companies will be building to order and there will be very little building for inventory. We advise consumers planning on a new boat for next season to zero-in on the desired boat now, so that you won’t be forced to buy whatever is left in May.


Link here: http://www.boattest.com/Resources/view_ ... ewsID=3898

Random thoughts (in no particular order)-

Production will double in 2010 on new boats if sales match 2009, as most of the left over 2007 and 2008 product is gone. The problem will be getting factories back up to speed.

This means that for those wanting to buy a new boat, it will be a case of taking what the dealer has in stock (if he has one in stock) or plan on waiting 3-4 months for a boat to be built. I expect factories to be slow to rehire workers until they know for sure that a recovery is under way. This will create additional backlogs initially.

Parts will be another area of hold up. We have been told that trailer parts (frames, axles and other large components) may not be available at this point until after January 2010, and to expect a back log as orders get filled. The steel plant won't even produce some components until more orders are in place. Many manufacturers will sit idle from now until January.

The industry slump continues, and dealers are still feeling the squeeze. So much so that many dealers are not going to be doing spring boat shows, or will have much smaller spaces. Product sold for little or no profit (and even some losses), and the reduction of available dollars for flooring hasn't helped, and factory money to help pay for show space may be reduced. Often this money is based on units sold, and with sales down, factory co-op money is down.

The Vancouver Boat Show has been cancelled for 2010. The Tacoma Dome Boat Show has been cancelled for 2010. The Portland Boat Show has been reduced to five days (and looks like it is a smaller show than last year).

Seattle will still encompass two weekends (How I wish it would go to a 5 day show! :cry: ), and may be the most important show in the Northwest for viewing product. Especially for C-Dory buyers, as there is no dealer in Portland anymore. We will be at the show, but expect a smaller display than 2009.

Buyers may experience sticker shock, as prices return to normal levels as distress sale "old" product is now mostly gone. Since Seattle Boat Show only allows showing of current product, or immediate previous model year product (2010 and 2009 for this year), even if any remaining stock still exists, it won't be at the show, and since only 50,000 2009 boats were built, expect much of what you see at the show to be 2010 stock.

C-Dory was one of the few builders (under Fluid) that built much 2009 product, so there will still be some of this at the show, and very aggresive prices, I'm sure. The problem now may be getting enough 2010 product to fill gaps in our inventory in time for the show.

Yamaha has announced the discontinuing of the Century product line effective immediately.

Brunswick has announced the recall of employees to the Meridian / Sea Ray plant, and also to the Hatteras plant, so there is some good news in the industry.
 
Thanks Matt for the industry update, some good and bad news, guess it depends if you are in the market for a new boat right now. I certainly hope the dealers will be in better shape and able to survive.
 
Matt: It appears you have sold all your 2009 inventory. What will you be coming to the show with? Is there still 2009 inventory out there? I can imagine what a jump in prices will be seen with the 2010 models, and the wait for manufacture and delivery.
 
Matt, and Sea Sport,

Looking forward to seeing you at the SBS in 2010. Thanks for the report. Do wish an improving season to both the dealers and the manufactures. These are still the boats that are out and about. Buy a boat you can afford to run and you won't have nearly as much "dock" time on the log book.

Harvey
SleepyC :moon
 
We have a few remaining 2009 models: 16 Cruiser, 19 Angler, 26 Venture. We have 22 Cruiser, 23 Venture and 255 Tomcat on order. Master Marine has a 22 Cruiser in production, so that may be the one at the show. They also have a 255 Tomcat in stock which could be displayed. We'll wait and see what arrives in time for the show.

Between the two of us, we should have a pretty complete display of models. Probably no 16 Angler, 22 Angler, 23 Venture or 25 Cruiser at the show uless something changes between now and then.

I'm most excited by the 23 Venture we have coming, as i think it will be a stunning boat as we have ordered it.
 
Matt Gurnsey":gtfwd90f said:
Seattle will still encompass two weekends (How I wish it would go to a 5 day show! :cry: ), and may be the most important show in the Northwest for viewing product. Especially for C-Dory buyers, as there is no dealer in Portland anymore.

Whoa - are you referring to Sportcraft? They still list C-Dorys at their site, and C-Dory still lists them as a dealer.

If so, that's a huge loss - they've had near universal praise here. Or, was there some other Portland area C-Dory dealer I've forgotten about?
 
I'm not sure what is going on. They are closed Sunday/Monday, when I just called I got their usual recorded message. On their website, they still list C-Dory but do not show any new or used inventory. I will try to call them Tuesday morning. Sure hope they are alive and well.
 
Matt Gurnsey":1ef9qykd said:
Saw this on another site, and found it interesting:

Stuff clipped...

Seattle will still encompass two weekends (How I wish it would go to a 5 day show! :cry: ), and may be the most important show in the Northwest for viewing product. Especially for C-Dory buyers, as there is no dealer in Portland anymore. We will be at the show, but expect a smaller display than 2009.

Stuff clipped...

OK Matt, spill it. What do you know that we folks here in Portland do not know? Sportcraft has always been a good dealer for me... I hope that they are not going to quit selling CDorys.
 
What I see in the Gulf Coast area (Orange Beach to Panama City, is a number of closed brokerages--both new and used. At least one Marine Max location out of business. Some brokers which had several locations, have pulled back to one. Or course Century was built in Panama City--and the read I get is that they are out of business at that location--do'nt know if some other location will build these in the future.

I visited with a delivary skipper this evening, who was taking a Hatteras 53 (1972) from Miami to Galveston--the new owner paid $80,000 for a good running boat! This is about 25% of what these boats were running a couple of years ago.

I see part of the problem in the next year as being credit. I also see boats as descritionary spending. Most likely the C Dory type and size will continue to be popular, but larger boats are way depressed. I was talking with a friend who consults on systems on many large vessel new builds--and he has been stiffed by several builders, who are completely shut down at this time. The lead time on many of these boats is several years. They seem to have a boat or two in production, but the staged payments are enough to cover costs of construction as the boat is built.
 
Matt,
In our business which has to do with security is usually up in a recession as gate operating devices are labor saving devices. Not this time. I think the long term effect of unemployment and years of uncontrolled gumint spending by both parties will make the next two years at least a real seesaw. The stock market moving up and 401k's rebounding are positive signs. People are scared (lenders and the public) and being a lot more careful. The economy is in a pretty fragile state IMHO. I wish the boat business the best, but I think it's down to rich guys and baby boomers retiring or retired already are what left of the boat buying pool. I do think there will be a growing number of bigger boat owners down sizing. I think C-Dory will do better than others. The little house on the water has great appeal, with them being trailerable, being cheaper to operate along with this forum will keep them alive.
D.D.
 
I stopped by Sportcrafts' new shop on a saturday back in november and there were almost no boats there. One new 25 and a whole bunch of motor parts lined up out in the storage area. Didn't look like they were doing much. The size of the facility didn't look like they planned on doing that much in the future. Wasn't even as big as EQ's facility.
 
A couple thoughts from this side of the FL. Panhandle .I have seen an uptick in business for us in the last few months , There has been some real estate sales in our area which sometimes correlate to boat sales for us . That is encouraging . We are slowly increasing selected inventory [like C Dory]while still shopping the bargains so we can make deals that are very good . I have some leftover C Dorys[16'-23'V] from another dealer[PM if you are interested in any] that I can sell at dealer invoice . When there are finally no leftovers left , we will get back to the new norm . Not sure what that is yet , but great boats , and great customer service will be a large part of it .
The Fisheries folks are killing the fishing boat industry for us [Amberjack closure recently] as well as other areas , with the closing of East Coast Red Snapper the other day , its another big blow to that segment .
I have had a few dealers around us close or will soon . Thats usually the guys that got in recently and thought it would be fun to sell boats . In our area the longer term dealers are pulled back and hanging in with service ,consignments and an occaisional new sale .
It looks like I will have at least one new C Dory for the Atlanta Show [1/13-1/17],along with the Ranger Tugs. But the bargains are still on the leftovers for now .
Marc
 
My understanding is that Sportcraft is still in business, but was forced to do some cut backs due to bank issues. Wasn't Sportcraft's fault, they just got caught up in the happenings beyond their control.

All their C-Dory and Skagit inventory went back to the bank. Whether they can still get product, I don't know. I don't beleive they have anything left in stock they could take to the show.

It's too bad, as I would stop by Sprtcraft in the early 80's to look at boats. I had no money, but always enjoyed walking the dock.

My understanding is that they were forced to move due to waterfront redevelopement. Apparently a boat business doesn't belong in the waterfront- at least as envisoned by some beaurocratic pinheads. :roll:
 
We purchesed our boat from them in the spring of 2009. At that time they were still in the old location and the new building was almost done. We were told the move was due to "road improvements" and they lost the area that they stored their boats in. By the looks of all the heavy equipment, gravel, orange cones, etc., I'm sure that is what was happening. Hope they overcome any distress they may be experiencing, they are a wonderfull group of people. I have had little contact with them since purchasing because the boat, motor, trailer and rigging have been free of any problems!
 
Here in San Diego, boaters are losing waterfront not to pinhead bureaucrats but to real estate developers. Boat yards are being moved to make room for the next big resort hotel. They then put in slips at $14/ft/mo

The developer has bought a politician (excuse me, contributed to his re-election campaign,) and the individual boater can't compete. The lower echelons of the bureaucracy may go against the developer, but once it reaches the elected official, the developer gets his return on investment.

I accept that this is the way of doing business, and not only in California, but throughout the nation. Florida is another prime example. Just find out where that road past Sportcraft goes and you'll have the answer. In Valley Centre the new 4 lane roads go to the Indian casinos.

As Will Rodgers said, we have the best government money can buy.

Boris
 
journey on":3djxbu69 said:
<lots of valuable commentary clipped>

As Will Rodgers said, we have the best government money can buy.

Boris

And if you want to find out why things happen, follow the money.....

Most folks are awed, shocked, and dismayed by the power of money controlling politics, but the Framers of the Constitution could never anticipate the modern economic machines that have their tentacles reaching into government.

Aside from that, I'll be looking forward to seeing everyone at the new, leaner, meaner, Seattle Boat Show and C-Brat Get-Together in late January!

Joe. :teeth :thup
 
RV industry in Indiana has slightly recoverd with some conslildation and some out of the business according to The Indianapolis Star newspaper (all news fit to be printed). Several RV and RV related companies in northern Indiana have hired back former or new employees with a new orders for RVs to be delivered in 2010. The roller coaster is heading back up in my words
 
Waterfront developement was over done in Florida in the years leading to the recession--and there are still lots of bargins there. A friend just bought a condo for 25% of what it was 3 years ago.

There is little new construction displacing marinas. Actually $14 a foot a month for S. Calif. is not bad--not much more than when I left there 18 years ago. However it does weed out the smaller and less expensive boats. Many marinas in S. Calif. are eliminating the slips less than 30 feet, where there has been availability.

I personally don't see a business climate conducive to boating recovery for some time. There are so many new unknowns in the tax and banking structures. I don't think that many of the baby boomers who had hung on for a year, are ready to make the retirement move yet. Although a segment of the market has recovered, there is most likely a barrier with the DOW close to $11,000--and there is a good likely hood of a second dip. Unempolyment will be down slightly this month, but early in the year it will most likely spike back up over 10.5% (not counting many who have given up looking for work, or who have run out of benefits).
 
In the good news column-

I had a nice chat with Larry at Sportcraft today. He wanted to be sure I knew they were still there, and still in business. I hope I didn't give the impression they weren't.

While they did get caught up in some bank issues, again, way beyond their control, they are still selling boats, motors and trailers, and will be continueing to service them as well.

As with many dealers, they may be stocking less to keep costs down, and will be focusing on service and parts to maintain a steady business. They are still one of the largest (if not the largest) Honda dealer in the country, and a strong Suzuki dealer.

Their plan is to continue to be a C-Dory dealer, but like many, will be ordering boats to order as customers want them. This reduces overhead, and helps customers get the boat they want, equipped as they want. It will mean some delay in geting a boat, but that looks like it will be the trade off for 2010 with most dealers.

Larry said they are also talking about going to the Portland Boat Show, which they haven't missed in something like 30 years.

I was glad to chat with Larry, as I said before, I spent many an afternoon years ago wandering around their docks in my youth. So Larry and his son Ryan will be there to take care of any local C-Brats, and from my visit, I can tell they are in good hands.
 
Back
Top