CStandard--some of the reviews with the words spray and slam may have been written by me. I considered three boats (after a lot of sea trials and reading--mostly in the fishing forums, where the cats are harshly reviewed.) I thought that going into the waves the Glacier bay 2690 had a better ride (but that was not free of spray and some noise). I found that the engines and trim made quite a bit of difference in the two Tom Cats which I sea trailed. The World Cat also has a good reputation--but the accomidations are no where those of the Tom Cat--Also the Glacier bay has a much smaller pilot house, does not seem to have quite as good fuel economy.
If I was going to be primarilly fishing I probably would have gone with the Glacier Bay 2690--however this is only based on performance into the waves:--down wind/waves, the Tom Cat 255 wins hands down. Not only wins--but remember that one of the Glacier bay 2690's capsized in what were described as moderate conditions and there was loss of life! That chinced the deal for me!
For a cruising boat--which can run in up to 3 foot surface chop--and 6 foot seas, the Tom Cat is fine--if you want to go to 4 foot chop--and that is huge--winds in the storm category--you might be better off with another boat. However in beam seas and down wind/seas the Tom Cat 255 is much better behaved. It slow speeds/trolling--the boat handled well.
I could have purchased any of these boats. I choose the Tom Cat. Reason is accomidation and layout, 8' 6" beam for trailering, quality of construction and handling in most conditions. As for it being "Crapola"--I think you need to really rethink that statement until after you have done some serious research.
If you notice my post on the boat I trialed at Wefinger's I was running at 24/25 mph along side a Regulator, 26 degree deep V--acknowleged to be one of the, if not the best riding monohulls in 3 foot seas, with no problems, except some spray in the cockpit--and occasional spray on the windshield. The wind was in excess of 18 knots and a fetch of about 10 miles.
If you check the Power Cat forum, you will find that some designers feel that 8' 6" beam is too little for a 26 foot boat....but that is a trade off. Every boat has some trade offs. Come one down to Pensacola after the first of July and I'll give you a ride.
Regards,