Long story of boat transport nightmare

Nan-C

New member
I started to put this on the thread about getting the new boat home. Then I realized this is probably too long to be appropriate there – or perhaps anywhere on the site. But I can’t resist. Your misfortune is that I cannot think of a better audience for a story I have been dying to tell.

The referenced thread begs my response for several reasons. Met Cory in Alameda a year or so ago. What an incredibly nice young man – probably because he is an Iowa boy. :D Truly, he is one of those guys who is the best of all worlds – a pleasure to deal with, makes you feel you are in great hands, and delivers on that promise.

As far as the cost of transporting a boat on its own trailer, like a C-Dory, I can make you feel better. Our Camano was just under $7K for the haul from Iowa to Alameda.

The transport deal I gave the buyer of our CD 25 was a little better. For fuel cost between Iowa and New Mexico, I drove from Alameda to Iowa, picked up the boat, and towed it to New Mexico and returned to Alameda. 4400 miles over a period of 9 days of which 5 were driving days. We spent a very enjoyable day-and-a-half with our buyers who were great people and a lot of fun and who insisted on paying for our two nights lodging overlooking Elephant Butte Lake. They certainly aided our recovery from the nightmare from which we had just recently escaped. Which brings me to the main reason for my response -- a long story that has been waiting for months to burst out. I’ll apologize in advance for the length of the story, but if you think reading it is long, you cannot imagine how long living it was.

It all started when we bought our Camano 31 in June and became a two boat, two payment family. I called Gerald Parker at Dudley Yacht Transport in Washington – knowing they are perhaps the premier big boat movers in the country – to get the boat sitting on the Mississippi transported to the Bay. Gerald, of course, wanted to avoid deadheading and was not sure when they could do it, so I started looking around. I finally settled on a hauler who sounded good, felt right, and seemed anxious to do the job – and sent him a $1500 deposit.

On the day I put the deposit in the mail Gerald – from Dudley – calls and says he has a driver headed back from New York who can pick us up two days later. I say I’m really sorry but I just mailed a deposit to another outfit. There’s a pause and Gerald – who is a very nice guy – quietly says he wishes I had not done that.

“You never give a deposit to anyone in our industry. There are too many crooks and frauds and fly-by-nights. The people who you want to hire do not need your deposit to get the job done and they are protected by having possession of your boat. We do not take a deposit.”

“Oh shit.” Followed by a little chit-chat, during which I realize the mailman – with my deposit letter – is driving back down the other side of our street. I tell Gerald and sprint out the door, waving my arms and leaping in front of the mail truck. The mailman – one of my former students – recovers from his heart attack quickly, sympathizes with my plight and hands me the envelope. I rip it in several pieces as I go back to the house. Shaking badly, I can’t find Gerald’s phone number, but within a few minutes he calls me back – relieved that I have retrieved my deposit check. In the course our conversation, I mention a few details about why I had thought the other hauler would be OK – including a glowing magazine article about him -- and some reasons for having had some concerns. It wasn’t long before Gerald says it sounds like Elmer. (Name changed to protect the innocent.)

“ Smith?” I say. “Elmer Smith?”

“Yeah. Elmer’s a great hauler. I’ve known him for years. Been in our yard many times. He’ll do a great job for you. I don’t want to pull a job out from under Elmer.”

So, I go to my computer, print another copy of the contract, write another check – so much for the dramatic tearing up of the envelope – and mail it. Oh, that this were the end of the story. It takes about two more weeks to get the boat actually picked up. We do the 6 hour round trip three times before we finally make arrangements for the pick-up to occur without us. Most of that time, the boat takes up limited parking in a busy marina that had wanted the boat set for two days at the most. I have to say they were very nice about it. In the end, Elmer calls and tells us one of his drivers will actually do the haul.

Big Jim – not real name – calls the day before the pick-up and introduces himself and tells us what to expect – including a daily phone call from him. Very professional. Very impressive. Boy did I feel good about him. For three days, both my wife and I enjoy his calls. He keeps us posted and gives us background details about his long career hauling boats – enough details for me to look him up on the Internet to get the information to send him a nice thank-you note at the end of the job. I cannot find him. But I do find a sound-alike name. Given what I find, I spend several hours saying the names out loud and assuring myself that, even with my poor hearing, I could not have misheard Big Tim as Big Jim. Finally, I pop for the ten or twenty bucks and do a reverse search on his cell number. “Oh shit,” again. Big Tim is hauling my boat. Big Tim whom I find all over the Internet, including a magazine article documenting an exceptionally difficult haul that he pulled off years ago that others would not undertake. Unfortunately, most of the rest – and there is a boat load of it – is not nearly as flattering. Deposits taken boats not hauled. Boats picked up, delivered weeks and sometimes months later. One boat still missing in action over a year later, A flybridge on a large, high-end yacht cut off with a reciprocating saw, electrical and hydraulics sheared with lopping shears. Court actions. One whole freaking website devoted to Big Tim -- by a victim -- and his crimes against boat owners. And he has our baby. Needless to say, intense nausea grips my stomach and refuses to let go for over a week.

I call Elmer. He finally deduces from my babbling what I have discovered. He laughs and assures me I have nothing to worry about. OK. So I maintain contact with Big Tim although now I am calling him more than he is calling me. Mechanical hang up in Wyoming. Fourth of July weekend travel barriers. Wide load issues near Truckee requiring a return to Reno. One reason after another for a three day trip dragging on and on. Finally several days of “I’ll be in the boatyard tomorrow.” But day after day the boatyard reports not getting their day-ahead notice. About nine days in, they get the call. Big Tim is in Arizona – miscommunication – it was actually Nevada – and would arrive the next day. I am going what the hell is he doing in Arizona? Next day, no boat. Another day and Big Tim gives the boatyard a story about Truckee road construction, returning to Reno, new permits, and highway numbers that make no sense to me. Again miscommunication. I get on the phone with Big Tim. The numbers he actually gave the marina do make sense. He assures me he’ll be in the boatyard by noon the next day. I talk to my guy at the boatyard. He is really feeling sorry for me now and volunteers to call Gerald Parker at Dudley to see what Gerald knows about this character. It is almost closing but he’s going to call me back in half an hour. Instead the office manager calls with some trivial information. Strange. Later I learn that what Gerald told them was so bad they did not have the heart to add to my misery. No sleep. Call the boatyard at 1:00. No boat. 2:00 no boat. Call Gerald Parker. Don’t know why, except I have to do something. Gerald evasive until he realizes I know so much that what he adds cannot make it worse. Confirms Big Tim is as bad or worse than anything I found on the Internet. Scourge of the industry for decades. Can’t explain what could possibly account for Elmer’s hiring him – a case of uncharacteristic bad judgment. Confesses his fear that the boat is sitting in Big Tim’s truck yard back in the Midwest or that Big Tim will demand payment before off-loading – Gerald knows that I have at this point paid Elmer in full.

4:00. I’m not vomiting but I’m close. Phone rings. My guy at the boatyard says “You know why I’m calling.” “To tell me my boat is there, I hope.” “ Greg, I’d like nothing more than to tell you that.” My heart sinks. My stomach does weird things. “And that is exactly why I am calling you. Congratulations.”

End of story: Every word Big Tim spoke for almost two weeks was basically true and accurate. He took care of the boat as if it were his own. Except for a three day trip taking almost two weeks, no one could have done a better job for us. Based on our experience, I could easily recommend his services – except for Gerald’s confirmation of all the horror stories.

So what is the moral? A story this long surely has to produce one. Ignorance is bliss? Don’t react prematurely and out of proportion? All’s well that ends well? One person’s nightmare is another’s interminably tedious story? The writer’s catharsis is the reader’s tedium? One man’s misery is another’s entertainment? Maybe it is simply to hire Cory. He is the whole package. For a big boat, Dudley gets my vote.

Again, I apologize and thank you for your indulgence!

Greg
 
Greg,

The old saw that says, "All's well that ends well" is right, unless you have a heart attach first.

Good story.

Harvey
SleepyC :moon
 
I think I know who this guy is, and if it is him, here is a story.

I sold a large trimaran in So Cal which had to be cut into three pieces and trucked to Florida in two loads. The first load was fine, then the hauler sublet the work to "Elmer Smith".

The boat was picked up, trucked across country and then Mr. "Smith" demanded an additional $3,000 above the contract or he would not deliver. The owner balked and refused the ransom so "Smith" 'stole' his boat and hauled it to Michigan.

The owner sued and finally got his boat delivered A YEAR later!

This same guy was arrested in Washington (my state), for not stopping at the Zebra mussel inspection station at the Idaho border. The state patrol had to chase down the boat and this "Smith" is wanted for failure to appear in court. The boat was infested with Zebra mussels.

This same guy threatened a Federal Marshall with death, and was dumb enough to do it on a recorded phone call. He spent some time before a Federal judge for that.

Greg, I think you should tell us his name to prevent other folks from being ripped off.
 
"Interminably tedious"? If I could write as well as you I'd be submitting stories about my visits to the Senior Center to the New Yorker.
 
Hi Larry --

I know you are right. I do feel torn because, based on our contact, we liked Big Tim, and he did a good job for us. The nightmare was always in my own mind and never in reality. Heck, the people at our boatyard liked him. Had I not discovered the distressing info, we would probably be singing his praises. But knowledge and circumstances made the move stressful beyond belief, and the volume of bad info speaks for itself. Given your mention of Michigan we undoubtedly both speak of Ed Perrin doing business most often as Global Yacht Transport. And people do need to know his story before they hire him.

Personally, we do wish Ed well and hope, given his mid-sixties age and our experience with him, he has turned over a new leaf. I truly hope that his association with the hauler we hired, whose reputation and references are impeccable, is moving him in a better direction.

Greg
 
That's the guy!

I don't have 'nice' feelings about this jerk, as he both screwed with a customer of mine AND he brought Zebra mussels into my state.

If anyone wants to know the story, and it's a good read, google search on Global Yacht Hauling - Roger Ed Perrin.


Larry H,
trying to 'keep it nice'
 
Greg,

I am happy to hear that you got your boat delivered. Camanos are a cool boat, kinda like a big C-Dory!

I used Dudley about twenty years ago and they did a great job.
 
In 1996, I moved from NY to VA and hired a FL hauler to move my 30' boat within a 30 day window. I gave the hauler $700 deposit and after two months and no boat, the hauler would not answer the phone, nor reply to mail. I filed a complaint with NY police, FL police and Boat US. After 3 months and no further communications with the hauler, I had to pay another shipper to move my boat and I never recovered any of my money. I had done research on this shipper and he appeared to be legit, but Boat US confirmed that he had burned many others for a lot more than I had lost.
Bottom line is you can be burned no matter what.
Best regards,
Steve Baum
 
What a terrible headache! I'm glad, though, that your boat arrived ok. Having recently had a boat transported I can attest to the value of C-brats for recommendations. I found Cory of Sharp Yachts Transport through the C-brats site and didn't need to go any further!
 
Hi there, Greg/Nan-C, glad you got your new boat where you wanted it.

Shipping a boat cross country has to be a frustrating experience. We shipped Our Journey, a 36' sailboat from San Diego to Mobile to go cruising, and after 2 years, back to the west Coast from Waukegan, Il to Los Angeles.

The first leg was easy. Since the boat was a Catalina sailboat, I called the Catalina factory and asked who (whom?) they used. They named several, I took the cheapest ($4000,) a guy in Sacramento. On the appointed day, up shows the trucker, the yard loads the boat ($400) and away he goes. 2 weeks later the boat shows up in Mobile, a week late, but OK. Turns out the guy in Sacramento was just a broker working through a clearinghouse somewhere in the South and all the haulers were independent truckers. The broker did get me a backhaul which was why it was so cheap. And the trucker invited me to his place when we hit the Florida Keys.

On the trip back, called the same guy. It was now $4500 and he pointed out that backhauls from east to west were scarce. I said OK, I'm in no hurry. I also tried some local haulers, but they were expensive, wanted me to drain the diesel tank and remove the batteries, etc. So I waited on the boat for a couple of weeks, hearing that the guy was "on the way." I finally came home, since the boatyard said they'd look after the boat and waited some more. Finally after about 2 months after calling the guy the boat arrived at LA. He had a boat on a trailer on the back of his truck, with Our Journey on a trailer. I guess he had a hard time finding a load and finally took the brokers price. Paid the guy (certified check,) and the yard launched the boat.

So what did I learn? First, hauling a boat cross country requires a lot of patience and some luck. Finding the name of a reputable guy is step one, and that has both an element of research and luck. Second I didn't have a clue how it works. The guy I used (Kevins Quality/Sean Bassham) didn't give me any insight, just said he'd haul it. One learns the details as you go along. But it certainly was shorter than sailing the boat through the Panama Canal. And I appreciate trailerable boats even more for the cruising range they give you, not necessarily the space they have.

Boris
 
I am confused? you said he did a good job but was two weeks late? which is it? you can't do a good job AND be late. being late is bad. I think after day two i would have been on the road looking for him.
 
By the time the boat was delivered, all I cared about was the boat not the when. The boat was properly loaded and arrived in perfect condition. I tend to be forgiving of some details -- in this case time. Also, I found that at least some of the reasons given for the late arrival were true and beyond the driver's control -- like the wide load restrictions on the holiday weekend. Maybe I should have qualified it as a good job except for extreme tardiness, but I often tell people I hire to worry about the quality not the time. Some people I know think I'm stupid that way. :D It also may be that nearly two weeks just seemed like a good job compared to the timelines experienced by others. :shock:

Greg
 
I just want to say, what a great writer and story-teller you are. Very fun read. :)

I personally can't imagine ever paying 7K to have a boat hauled to me, but I'm cheap...I mean frugal :)
 
I have to second everything that has been said about Cory Gracey of Sharp Yachts Transport.

I have had the priviledge of teaching two of the three children in the family, one when I taught 4th grade and the youngest now in 5th grade.

I remember meeting Mrs. Gracey at parent/teacher conferences and was very impressed with the family values. I soon met Cory at the Seattle Boat Show and introduced myself. At the time they had a boat dealership in Everett, WA selling Twin Vee cats built in Florida. After talking with Cory, I thought, "Now I know why their daughter is such a hard worker in my 4th grade class."

I have referred Cory to potential customers on another boat owners website and enjoy hearing that people are impressed by his service, professional personality and work ethic.

When we were looking at buying in August 2010, I was ready to buy an east coast boat because I knew who I would have hired to transport it. We instead found a local Washington boat, which is our gem now.

Being a great transporter does have its drawbacks, though. I know Cory is away from home a lot and his family sure misses him. On the plus side, I'm sure Cory will find willing and able employees to carry on the gold standard that he has established in boat transport.

BTW, I loved the story, Greg.

Patrick
 
A well-told story, Greg. I certainly understand your feelings... you got your boat, it was fine. You may have a few new gray hairs because of the delay, but that's easily forgiven when you're at the helm. :wink:

So, how are you enjoying the bigger boat?

Best wishes,
Jim B.
 
Thanks to all for the kind words. I often enjoy the story of another's comedic trials and tribulations so it seemed only fair to share mine. As I mentioned to Larry in a PM, I did not get the hoped for cathartic effect when I was banging it out. My blood pressure actually skyrocketed -- and I'm on medication.

Without dragging this too far in the direction of a non-C-Dory, I will say we love the bigger boat. As has often been mentioned on this site, the best boat is the right boat for the purposes of the user. We were living on the C-Dory more and more in Alameda -- 9 months out of the last 18 we owned it. Nancy was beginning to whine a little about what she called "living butt-to-butt and bell-to-belly." Personally, I saw that as one of the advantages. Anyway, the additional space and volume have been very nice and this year we will be on the boat for at least seven months. I never want to leave it, but then I never wanted to take the C-Dory out of the water. We will really miss the trailering and the rivers and the lakes and the Keys -- and boating once in a while in places where we don't have kids who need a babysitter when the sky is blue and the water beckons and the boat wants out of her slip. :) But I guess we traded all that for a flybridge where we can lounge, sip wine, and listen as the soft crack of distant gunfire wafts across evening water from Oakland. We both wish we could have kept the C-Dory, too. Where was that winning lottery ticket when I needed it? Guess you have to buy them to have chance, huh?

Regards to all,

Greg
 
Back
Top