I am guilty on several occasions of criticizing a boats listing price.. Each time, I thought about it--and in some cases posted, other cases did not.
Recently I posted about the Tom Cat for sale at about its original cost. I have considerable knowledge about these specific boats, and what the selling price should be because of recently selling one. I have also seen several of the boats currently on the market which are similar. Now, any sale requires a willing seller and willing buyer. Setting a realistic price will be of a benefit to the seller, as well as a buyer. If a seller thinks his boat is worth more--then he can justify this, (this is to his credit and may help him obtain more for the boat). Or he can have a faster sale with a realistic price.
In this case, I gave some reasons why I felt that boat should be priced a bit lower. I received some positive feedback off list on those posts. Many times new boaters do not realize what determines the "value" of any particular boat. In the C Dorys there are many factors: Age, condition, Trailer, stove, kept in salt water, lift kept, fresh water boat, inside storage and damage etc. But also specific equipment. For example, a Tom Cat Trailer is far more expensive than a C Dory single axle yard trailer. There are changes made at the factory--and a boat with some of the upgrades is worth more.
I see many facets of this web site--social functions, learning functions, purchase functions etc--but the final decision of what "goes" is up to the owners of the site.
I hope that comments are not limited on the "for sale" boats. This is from the prospective of a person who has sold 3 C Dories in the last few years, and may be going to buy a 22 again. There are questions which are general interest. Unfortunately many people who list the boats don't come back to our site on a regular basis.