Need advice!

boat4vns

New member
The wife and I are considering becoming first time boat owners. We're looking for something trailer-able with some creature comforts. Have narrowed it down to C-Dory 22 Cruiser or and Arima 21/22 hardtop. We're in our early fifties so traveling at displacement speed with heat and a head while being protected from the elements is good. Need some insight what to look for and what is a fair price. Any help would be appreciated.
Thanks in advance!
:D
 
There is so much information on this site in reference to about any question you could ask. There is a search engine, put in some key words and you will have lots of reading.
 
I love my CD-22. It is easily trailerable, and I can launch and retrieve it single-handed with ease.

The "head" is a porta-potti (the CD-26 has an enclosed room with shower).

For heat, I use a Buddy Heater, which works great.
 
boat4vns-

Simply put, the CD-22 Cruiser is a better cruising and overnight boat, whereas the Arima is more suited to daytime fishing. The C-Dory canalso be used as a "BoaterHome", a camper while dry on the trailer!

The Arima also requires more horsepower, and therefore more gas.

Les Lampman of EQ Marine at Oak Harbor on Whidby Island, has been a dealer for both boats for years, but presently no longer a C-Dory dealer. He does have a used C-Dory 22 in stock, and probably a new or used Arima 21 or 22 HT. Go see both boats side by side and think it through. Your intuition should tell you a lot about how you'll feel in the two boats. Les can also offer better advice comparing the two boats than anyone else on this site.

Read as much as you can here on this site and also on the Arima Owner's Site. Our site is a treasure trove of information on both C-Dorys and boating in general.

Give yourself several month's to think it over, if necessary.

You could also see both boats at the Seattle Boat Show in January, but may just come away overwhelmed with information about hundreds of other boats as well.

Stop by and see us at the C-Brat Get Together and Boat Show in January and see what a great group of owners we have, almost like a great big family. Information on this event is forthcoming soon.

I personally recommend the CD-22 over the Arima from what you've said about yourselves.

Right now, during the economic slowdown, there are some very good buys on used C-Dorys as well as other boats. See the listings on our Homepage bottom right corner.

Good Luck!

Joe. :teeth :thup
 
These were the same two boats we thought about for months. I looked for a used one of either model- Arima or C-Dory, but we ended up with a new C-Dory and havent regreted it. Les a E.Q. is the guy to talk to. He has the knowledge and experience. Dont forget Roseborow- that might be the ultimate boat but again more money and do you have something that can pull it? Good luck. RJ
 
Hands down the c-dory is a more comfortable boat to "live on". The Arima's are great boats and very seaworthy but are just a little more of a fishing boat. Also, the head room in the Arima with the HT is much less than in the c-dory. I'm not sure what the inside height is of the Arima but I do know that if you are 6' you won't be able to stand up.
 
Hi there,

I was an Arima 17 owner, and now have a CD 22. We considered both the Arima 21 and 22, but decided that the CDory 22 would do more of what we wanted (cruise and fish) at less price, with lower power needs, and more of a community of fellow boat nuts.

It sounds like you've nearly made up your mind on a CDory, so here is what I would put on it, and what additional decisions you'll need to make.

I would start with power... Many of us are now going with bigger main engines with a small kicker. Usually a 90-115 HP main, and an 8 or 9.9 HP kicker. This seems to be a good setup for fishing as well as cruising. If your focus is going to be primarily cruising, you might consider a set of twins in the 40 - 50 HP range. You can also fish these, but you may not be able to troll down as slow. I'll let the folks with twins chime in.

I recommend at least two batteries. One for starting, and another for the house. I have a group 24 start and group 27 for the house, on a manual switch, rather than an electronic switch. Make sure that the dealer locates your batteries so you can get at them. Mine were originally both in the starboard lazarette, and I had to move them to make access easier, as well as do a better job balancing the boat.

I would also have either (and probably both) trim tabs or Permatrim. The help significantly with trimming the boat to run in rougher/choppy water.

I would have a very good sonar/fishfinder/gps system, with some kind of a backup. I use a Raymarine C80 (sonar/gps/radar) as my primary, and a Humminbird 757 sonar/gps as a backup. I recommend a good fixed VHF, and possibly two or maybe a handheld.

I have a Wallas on board Constant Craving, and I like it, but many of the CBrats have had issues with theirs. You might consider a small Force 10 heater and another type of stove/heater.

A number of folks have anchor winches, but we have not sprung for that one yet.

We do not have a washdown pump, and I don't miss it. I really don't want any through hull fittings, and besides, they go gunny sack often.

If you get an older boat where the bilge is in the bridge deck into the cabin, consider a second bilge pump. I carry a manual, but I would like to upgrade either to a Whale Gusher style pump, or have a second electric.

If you keep the boat in the water a lot, I would have a barrier coat applied, followed by bottom paint. If you intend to trailer a lot, consider a double axle trailer, as they ride smoother (harder to handle in tight situations) and they give you backup safety in the event of a blow out.

I would also recommend a fixed boarding ladder as well as interior grab handles. If you go for an unexpected swim, it makes things easier to get back on. The grab handles are good protection from bumps on the noggin when you're moving around in chop. They also make handy clothes lines.

OK, enough rambling, and that looks like more than 2 cents worth...

Kind Regards,

Steve
 
All good advice, Steve --

After 5 Arima and 7 C Dory boats, I still think it is purely a personal lifestyle choice. I'll be shrimping tomorrow on my partner's 21 Arima (150 Honda), really like the 22 Arima Les has at EQ -- and we personally have a 22 C Dory -- and my son-in-law has a 22 C Dory. Boat poor, eh??

Both great boats, built for our NW water, and the choice depends upon you future use. There is very little difference in MPG figures at trawler speeds, and quite close at a reasonable cruise. BUT, a huge BUT -- the Arima is a bigger boat, can carry a lot more fuel, etc. if you wish. And when you get heavier the mpg numbers go down. The 22 Arima (at least my 22 Arima) is a lot more comfortable if the water is messy -- I didn't say safer, just a lot more comfortable. It's quieter in rough water, and is a full flotation hull. So ya pays yer money and takes yer choice! Again, they are both great boats, and you future use should be the deciding factor. There are good buying opportunities out there right now...

HTH,

Dusty
 
Wandering Sagebrush":15awb7jq said:
We do not have a washdown pump, and I don't miss it. I really don't want any through hull fittings, and besides, they go gunny sack often.

Steve, You might consider adding a washdown that's tied into the fresh water tank. That's what I did. It's pretty easy to "T" into the line under the sink. I mounted the pump under there as well and then came out the hole in the bulkhead that's under the starboard gunnel. Of course you dont' get endless washdown but 20 gallons goes a long way. The pumps location is dry and I believe this increases the pumps life. Anyway, just passing it along.

c_dory_007.sized.jpg

c_dory_002.sized.jpg
 
Back
Top