Tony-
Nice hearing from you again!
The Call Girl Theory works for 5-6 footers, not sure for 3-4 footers!
Thanks for clarifying which "C.G." reference you're refering to.
The C.G. = Coast Guard is the way science (physics) measures everything, from the zero point in the middle. But almost everybody else goes from trough to crest, adds in a bit of adrenaline or otherwise induced exaggeration, so their (C.G.) "objective" system often seems out of kilter with what folks think they experience, by comparison!
Typical situation: the C.G. wx report says three footers, the Weekend Fishing Fanatic listens to the forecast, then goes out to find waves six feet from trough to crest-- which he sees as eight footers, and the complaints about the wx report begin................!
I'm not going to belittle anyone else's water body size, or the size of any other part of their body, for that matter! I just know I'm here on a relatively calm inland lake, and, although I've experienced a fair share of big chop on S.F. Bay and swells in the ocean on sailboats, there are no real waves for me here or anyone else on a similar (much smaller than yours) sized body of water to go out and test out some of these boathandling theories and lecture to the world! If you want that, you ask Dusty!
Roger-
"a great deal of agreement" would have to be a relative term!
No agreement issues:
single vs twins
best motor brand
best anchor type
etc., etc.
In Agreement non-issues: (but also non-technical!)
C-Dory = best boat for our type of boating!
Mike and Bill do a great job!
C-Brat Get Togethers = FUN!!!
**************************
Joe.