OK, I have to chime in here, as I have both a Brinkman electric water smoker and a Lil Chief. The Brinkman has a lot higher temp than the Lil Chief, probably 100° F. higher, so it depends what you are going after. The Brinkman really just sort of cooks the fish and of course adds smokey flavor, the Lil Chief has more of a drying action. I use the Brinkman to smoke ribs, pork butts, picnics, etc. - it is really for 'cue in my mind, with hickory or mesquite chunks. I use the the Lil Chief to smoke fish, snack sausage, etc., with sawdust in the pan.