A Fishin C is pretty close. Your memory is pretty well intact... indeed, much better then mine!
Checking the actual paperwork.... We bought our 23' Venture new at the 2008 SBS (Seattle Boat Show) at which time the "Boat Show Special Price" listed was $62,495.
Out the door the total including WA. State Sales Tax, rigging - we added a double burner Wallas, an 8-HP Yamaha kicker, 2nd battery, rebuilt swim platform and ladder (heavy duty to support SCUBA divers), grabrails on the transom, EZLDR bunk trailer guides, and a few other dive related items and license and registration came to $72,786.
Our boat is equipped w/ a Yamaha 115 HP motor and also came w/ a EZLoader Dual Axle galvanized trailer. As far as needing to have a little more OOMPH from a bigger motor; since this is the 1st boat we have ever owned I cannot really comment (nothing to really compare it to) except to say that on smooth water we have had it up to about 32 knots which is plenty fast for us.
My wife does indeed greatly enjoy the boat but has looked longingly at the larger models (25's, 26's, and Tomcats) having a head and shower especially on our longer forays (a few cruises up to 9 days). Moving up to a bigger boat would however involve a major investment since we would need to upgrade our tow vehicle also so will not happen anytime soon.
The main C-Dory accessory (not listed above) - which has been almost priceless to us - justifying the entire purchase is participation in the C-Brats and attending numerous CBGTs where we have met many wonderful people.
Tanks,
Dan & Tanya Denver