Owners have tried new gaskets, strong backs to keep the hatches rigid, new hatches, and even an occasional case of a raised hatch (such as on the lazarette of the 22's, to no avail.) My son's Cruise Ship 25 seems to have dry bilges, but that may be because it is in S. Calif. and he keeps the slant back over the cockpit.
The only plastic one which has been tested with water, and this is a new hatch, so we don't know what time will do, is the
Innovative Product Solutions Boat Hatch 520-625 | Polar White 12 x 26 This is about $120. This has no hinges, and uses a wedge structure on the back to give the pressure.
There are some great aluminum, casketed hatches which are truly water tight such as this Bowmar:
The 15 x 24 starts at $529. Is it worth $1200 to keep the bilge dry? For some it may be. If I were to buy a 25 again, I would consider putting these hatches in.
In any case, when you put in a new hatch, the cockpit deck core needs to be cut back, filled with thickened epoxy, and then installed, with the screws into the epoxy.