We have trim tabs (Bennett) and Permatrims. We cruised for two years with trim tabs alone and two with both. With trim tabs alone we used them for fore and aft trim plus lateral trim. They worked fine but we noticed a bit of lugging when we had them way down to get the bow down. It took a little experience to figure out how to be delicate and get the most good from them. With permatrims too we use the trim tabs just for lateral trim and they are great. The Permatrims give us good fore and aft trim and there is adequate range to allow us to move the bow in a wide variety of water conditions. There too, if we over trim, we notice some very minor lugging and lower fuel economy. Together they make a very nice combination and with a little experience, make traveling much smoother. If I had to choose one, I'd go with the trim tabs and I would definitely go with the auto retract feature so they come up when the engines are shut down.