My boat is set up with the pump auto being off of the starboard engine battery and the manual switch being off the house battery. Because I have twins, I'm not concerned about the Starboard engine battery running down because of a stuck sump pump switch. If I had a single engine, I'd want to run both switches off my house battery. But, in these days of being able to combine house and start for emergency start, it probably matters little what the exact configuration you are using. Because I don't leave my boat in the water for extended time without being on board, I don't really have the stuck bilge pump switch issue either. Most of you who do leave your boats in, stay on dock power as well, so you probably don't have much issue with the configuration either, (relative to running down a battery cuz of a stuck bilge pump switch).