16 foot angler vs cruiser?

pub · Posted: Wed Mar 15, 2006 4:50 pm Post subject: 16 foot angler vs cruiser?

does anyone have working advantages of either boat version. Are both just as sea worthy? and what do you all think about the re-sale value is between the two.

Thanks all
:0)
Shawn and Marcy
we will one one soon. our main use will be as a cummuter boat and short island runner. but will experience 3 foot waves here and their.

Rabbits Hutch · Posted: Wed Mar 15, 2006 6:46 pm Post subject:

Hi Shawn and Marcy,

Last year I went through the same exact search and decided upon the 16' Cruiser model for numerous reasons.

The hull is the same on both models and their ability to handle the conditions you suggest is no problem at all for this tough little boat. The decision you need to make is between wanting a v berth and more cabin space versus the need for a larger fishing cockpit and no bed/smaller cabin.

We choce the cruiser as it was better for weekend fun trips around puget sound. The cruiser model offers a small table in front of the passenger seat which was just great for picnics on board. Also, having the v berth made camping out a snap. We added a full camper canvas package from king marine to give us a ship shape, bullet proof craft. When we wanted to fish, both chairs swiven and face aft...so it was a breeze. And, the generous cabin space on the 16 cruiser made cooler days enjoyable.

Either way you will be getting a great boat. Just decide do you want a fishing machine or a cruiser that you can still fish with???

Ponder ponder ponder...

Let me know if I can be of any more help.

Gary R.

DAVEY5205 · Posted: Thu Mar 16, 2006 12:28 am Post subject: 16ft

hello we have a angler and also found its a decision on whether you want deck space for fishing or cabin comfort space. we are in the process of trying to adapt our angler for a overnight campout. we just put a camper back on and now comes the task of how we sleep? so for a fishing day trip, use the angler, or a comfy joy ride and occasional camper use a cruiser. both are very good boats!!!!

hughpenk · Posted: Thu Mar 16, 2006 2:04 pm Post subject:

I'm happy with my 2003 16 cruizer as it is more versatile. I can fish off the boat when it's time, but due to the low draft and all the boat begs to be a gunkholer and explore where the kayaks go. The vee berth and beachability make it a bit more comfortable than tent camping for sure. I don't think I would sacrafice the cruizer ability for more cock-pit space. If I were fishing 2 people on the boat would be preferrable or maybe 3 with one person just sitting. I don't know if the cock-pit of the angler would make it that much more room to add more people. An angler owner may speak to how much the increased cock-pit space matters. Good luck- choices are the fun part of life!

fiddlersgreen6 · Posted: Thu Mar 16, 2006 10:19 pm Post subject:

Shawn & Marcy--- My 16' cruiser has been in the Atlantic and Pacific, the Intercoastal, the Chesapeake, the Gulf of Mexico, the Erie Canal, the Ohio & Mississippi Rivers, Kentucky Lake and varoius inland lakes in the U.S. In all conditions, and I have found the cruiser to be totally reliable and seaworthy.I'm sure the same can be said for the Angler, since they are basically the same hull. It is actually the biggest 16' boat I have ever owned. Most small boats do not have much freeboard so you can only sit in them, and cramped at that, but you can stand in the 16 making for a lot more comfort and less aches and pains even on all day trips. Loading and unloading is also breeze.

I recently had a good laugh at a rest stop in Arkansas, I overheard two guys talking about my boat, one guy that was looking in my windows, was telling his buddy that my boat had a dining room, bathroom, bedroom, and even a patio all crammed into that little space. --- - - - - Rich

fiddlersgreen6 · Posted: Fri Mar 17, 2006 12:37 pm Post subject:

Shawn & Marcey--- I forgot to mention my thoughts about your question on pricing. The 16 Cruiser is higher priced than the Angler to begin with, so this may hold true on resale also. Alot would also depend on the type of equipment on the boat. I have owned several boats( 50 or more), and I really feel that the C-Dory gives the best return overall on your investment. Some people I know have actually came close to breaking even after owning a C-Dory for 5 years or more. Alot also depends upon how well the boat has been maintained, I've seen 5 year old C-Dory's that I wouldn't touch. Good Luck Rich

fiddlersgreen6 · Posted: Sun Mar 19, 2006 3:07 pm Post subject:

Shawn & Marcy---have you heard from anyone with a 16' Angler? It wouldn't hurt to get a different opinion, on the two models? There are a few of this model that use to be pretty active on this site. Rich

DaveS · Posted: Sun Mar 19, 2006 7:53 pm Post subject:

Hi Shawn and Marcy,
I had a 16' Cruiser before we purchased our 22'. You mention that you plan on using the vessel to commute in somewhat bumpy water. I'm not a fisherman, so ours was used more for cruising. My thoughts would be that you go with the cruiser as that gives more cabin space, more protection from the elements larger V-Berth for stowage or snoozing and along with the larger cabin, better deflection of waves (hence less water in in the vessel, if waves get too heavy.........course I'd be trying to get the boat back to land at that point).

(Realize that I've never cruised in a 16' Angler, so you'll have to wait until Brock (Catman) sees this and gives his eloquent opinion..........How about it Brock?)

fiddlersgreen6 · Posted: Mon Mar 20, 2006 1:18 pm Post subject:

Which ever model you decide on, besure and get a stern room or at the very least a good strong bimini top, this will surely make any crossings alot more comfortable.---- Rich