The C-Brats Forum Index
HomeForumsMy TopicsCalendarEvent SignupsMemberlistOur C-DorysThe Brat MapPhotos

Composting toilets vs. regulations
Goto page 1, 2  Next
 
Post new topic   Reply to topic    The C-Brats Forum Index -> Wastewater Systems
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
tomherrick
Guest





PostPosted: Tue Oct 18, 2016 12:08 pm    Post subject: Composting toilets vs. regulations Reply with quote

I've been hoping to install a composting toilet on our boat as part of our C-Dory rebuild. We also hope to spend time in the waters of Ontario, Canada and Key West, Florida where the rules regarding sewage disposal are pretty tight.

I've put in a call to the Ontario Ministry of Environment and Climate Change regarding the regulation posted below. After being transferred several times, I got a voice mail box that I don't expect to be returned; but I'll keep trying on this. This is a question that is not conclusively answered on many, many boating forums. If I'm able to get an answer that is authoritative I'll post it everywhere I can.

The one possible opening for compliance is shown in red in this paragraph:

(d) equipment designed for the incineration and storage of human excrement is supplied with such electrical current or other source of heat as is necessary to reduce to ash all excrement deposited therein

Since organisms that break down excrement might be technically considered a "source of heat", perhaps this would be interpreted as being in compliance.



I don't have the Key West regs, but here's the Ontario regulation as it currently stands:

Environmental Protection Act
R.R.O. 1990, REGULATION 343
DISCHARGE OF SEWAGE FROM PLEASURE BOATS
Consolidation Period: From February 12, 2007 to the e-Laws currency date.
Last amendment: O. Reg. 35/07.
This is the English version of a bilingual regulation.
1. In this Regulation,
“pleasure boat” means a boat used primarily for the carriage of a person or persons for pleasure, whether on charter or not, and whether for compensation or not, and includes a boat used on water for living purposes; (“bateau de plaisance”)
“sewage” means organic and inorganic waste, and includes fuel, lubricants, litter, paper, plastics, glass, metal, containers, bottles, crockery, rags, junk or similar refuse or garbage, and human excrement, but does not include,
(a) liquid wastes, free of solids, from water used in a pleasure boat for household purposes, or
(b) exhaust wastes, cooling water and bilge water from a pleasure boat; (“eaux d’égout”)
“storage equipment” means equipment of a design and construction suitable for the storage or the incineration and storage of human excrement in a pleasure boat including such equipment that is an integral part of a toilet; (“appareil d’entreposage”)
“toilet”, in relation to a pleasure boat, means equipment designed or used for defecation or urination by humans. (“cabinet de toilette”) R.R.O. 1990, Reg. 343, s. 1.
2. No person shall discharge or deposit, or cause or permit to be discharged or deposited, into any water, sewage from a pleasure boat. R.R.O. 1990, Reg. 343, s. 2.
3. The owner and the operator of every pleasure boat in which a toilet is installed shall ensure that, while the boat is on water,
(a) the boat is equipped with storage equipment; and
(b) such toilet and storage equipment are installed so as to be non-portable. R.R.O. 1990, Reg. 343, s. 3.
4. The owner of a pleasure boat in which a toilet or toilets and storage equipment are installed shall ensure that each toilet and the storage equipment are installed so that,
(a) the toilet and equipment are connected in such a manner that the equipment receives all toilet waste from the toilet;
(b) equipment designed for the storage of human excrement is provided with a deck fitting and such connecting piping as is necessary for the removal of toilet waste by shore-based pumping equipment;
(c) no means of removal of toilet waste is provided other than the means mentioned in clause (b);
(d) equipment designed for the incineration and storage of human excrement is supplied with such electrical current or other source of heat as is necessary to reduce to ash all excrement deposited therein; and
(e) all parts of the system for removal of toilet waste are congruent with one another and the boat. R.R.O. 1990, Reg. 343, s. 4.
Back to top
Will-C



Joined: 21 Aug 2007
Posts: 2476
City/Region: Temple
State or Province: PA
C-Dory Year: 2008
C-Dory Model: 23 Venture
Vessel Name: Will-C
Photos: Will-C
PostPosted: Tue Oct 18, 2016 1:32 pm    Post subject: Composting toilets vs. regulations Reply with quote

Just a couple comments. I think the idea of composting toilets are great.
But it still leaves you with having to deal with liquid waste. I they have a holding tank for liquids. The other problem as some users have noted that the diverter valve must be switched when doing the liquid thing. Some folks have a hard time not doing both at the same time. I have a friend who actually keeps a turd log if you can believe it. I wonder if the whiz just gets dumped where ever, over the side. The Keys have no discharge zones where I think that would be frowned upon. I like most fisherman have taken a leak over the side of the boat. But I would not do that in a marina. Carrying the whiz container to the marina bathrooms might be awkward. My wife vetoed the Airhead concept. I'm sure others will chime in on the pro's and cons. I think in Key West and probably all the Florida keys Airheads are an acceptable option instead of conventional holding tank systems. I remember the book Yellow River by I.P. Daily.
D.D.

_________________
Chevrolet The Heart Beat Of America
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
bobjarrard



Joined: 03 Oct 2010
Posts: 458
City/Region: Boulder City
State or Province: NV
PostPosted: Tue Oct 18, 2016 2:12 pm    Post subject: composting toilet Reply with quote

I know that our Canadian neighbors want a pump out and that a hand carried porta potti bottom does not fit the rule. This means that no existing composting toilet fits the bill. I have a C-Head composting toilet (http://www.c-head.com/) waste needs to be dumped say every two to four weeks if you have heavy use by two (assuming the paper goes to a bag for burning or tossing). In most of the US, this toilet is OK. Some folks when they go North have a pump out toilet put in place, many do not and seem to get through the border OK. I guess you could put in the pump out deck fitting, run some pipe down to the toilet and hope they do not look. I for one would not have a holding tank on another boat.
Bob
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail AIM Address
tomherrick
Guest





PostPosted: Tue Oct 18, 2016 2:13 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Quote:
I have a friend who actually keeps a turd log if you can believe it.


Freeze dried or in a baggie??? Rolling Eyes

I actually got two calls back from the Ontario Ministry of Environment and Climate Change. The guy I talked to said they'd not had an enquiry on this subject before and that he - from the Toronto regional office - had been in touch with the Provincial office and they were going to discuss it. I'm taking that as a positive note at this point since they didn't just quote the letter of the law, but are going to have some internal talks and, hopefully, provide legal guidance that can be shared.

@Bob I heard/read somewhere that the AirHead owner suggested installing a pumpout fitting on the side deck with a line to the solids tank. That might technically meet specs, but who knows. I'm hoping for a clearly stated allowance for the composters...

T
Back to top
thataway



Joined: 02 Nov 2003
Posts: 20779
City/Region: Pensacola
State or Province: FL
C-Dory Year: 2007
C-Dory Model: 25 Cruiser
Vessel Name: thataway
Photos: Thataway
PostPosted: Tue Oct 18, 2016 3:29 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Quote:
. In this Regulation,
“pleasure boat” means a boat used primarily for the carriage of a person or persons for pleasure, whether on charter or not, and whether for compensation or not, and includes a boat used on water for living purposes; (“bateau de plaisance”)
“sewage” means organic and inorganic waste, and includes fuel, lubricants, litter, paper, plastics, glass, metal, containers, bottles, crockery, rags, junk or similar refuse or garbage, and human excrement, but does not include,
(a) liquid wastes, free of solids, from water used in a pleasure boat for household purposes, or


Looking up the definition of human excrement it appears in most cases to include both human feces and urine. One can make the argument that urine is sterile, and is probably "cleaner" than shower or dish water. But if you go by the letter of the law....the only head which would be legal would be an incinerator, --leaving only ash, and a container which could only be pumped out at a shore pump out station.
The flow thru type I or II, such as Purasanj or Electrosan (macerator and clorination, are not allowed.

The composting toilet does require the organic matter and feces to be disposed of at some point in shoreside waste containers, and certainly is not in a state to be pumped out at a marine pump out facility. The urine which is defined as human excrement, has to be dumped at some point--and fairly regularly when living aboard.

Best to be ignorant--Now they have Tom's name, and if he does violate the law???Another way is to have no sanitary facilities aboard the boat. Just use shore facilities (of course it is not going to be done).

I am not a fan of the "diaper" type of containment system, since the fecal material is not handled like toxic waste--as it should be. There can easily be pathogens, and these can leak out into the environment--think 3rd world conditions...

Air head makes the statement:

Quote:
Yes, “Air Head” Composting Toilet is classified as a MSD type III.



During my cruising days (1982-1986), most of our areas were not under any "no discharge regulation". Even in 1992 thru 1996, there were few pump out stations in BC., Alaska. Many in the US were not maintained. I am not a fan of holding tanks, because there was no place to have them pumped out. We used shoreside facilities where ever possible, in marinas. I had an aqua lift for the generator. Of course this was in the hot engine room--and even though I was "inspected" by US CG--they seemed to buy that the aqua lift appeared to be a holding tank. This would not work in today's world. There still is an issue even in the great lakes that pump out facilities are few and far between--some are broken, some have never even been installed.

So the answer to the question is that in the US, including
Great Lakes and US inland lakes the composting is a class III device.
(But so is a porti potty!)

_________________
Bob Austin
Thataway
Thataway (Ex Seaweed) 2007 25 C Dory May 2018 to Oct. 2021
Thisaway 2006 22' CDory November 2011 to May 2018
Caracal 18 140 Suzuki 2007 to present
Thataway TomCat 255 150 Suzukis June 2006 thru August 2011
C Pelican; 1992, 22 Cruiser, 2002 thru 2006
Frequent Sea; 2003 C D 25, 2007 thru 2009
KA6PKB
Home port: Pensacola FL
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
tomherrick
Guest





PostPosted: Tue Oct 18, 2016 3:45 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

OK, well, here’s the straight poop from the Ontario Ministry of Environment and Climate Change:

He just called back to say that the regulation is old and doesn’t take into account composting, incinerating, or other ‘newer’ technologies. The old regs were written to disallow any physical means to empty waste overboard. I was told that new regulations are under discussion that will address new technology. But in the meantime, if I install a composting toilet and store any accumulated waste in the toilet or otherwise onboard, then dispose of it properly onshore there will be no problem.

I wish there was written regulation that addresses this issue, but there isn’t as yet. For me – a by-the-book kinda guy - I’m now totally comfortable with installing a composting toilet and making provisions with an air-tight container to hold bagged waste for onshore disposal.

Now to figure out the NOAA requirements for the Marine Sanctuary in the Florida Keys…
Back to top
Pat Anderson



Joined: 02 Nov 2003
Posts: 8551
City/Region: Birch Bay, WA
State or Province: WA
C-Dory Year: 2005
C-Dory Model: 25 Cruiser
Vessel Name: Daydream
Photos: Daydream and Crabby Lou
PostPosted: Tue Oct 18, 2016 4:38 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

I posted the question of composting toilets the AGLCA (America's Great Loop Cruisers Assocation) form, and got many, many response from boaters using composting toilets.

First off, nobody ever had a problem in Canada using a composting toilet. Most people responded that the liquid tank was carried to an on-shore public toilet for emptying when available, and they hoped for a moonless night when not available! We have never been concerned about dumping the liquid tank out in the open water. Although urine, I have learned through Google, is not actually sterile, "dilution is the solution." I would not dump it in a marina, in the Erie canal, or other restricted waters, but in those circumstances, there is always going to be a restroom available.

The composted solids were emptied every three or four weeks (remember this is continuous use from months on the Loop, we empty ours once a year with weekend and summer cruising). The composted solids look like garden soil, honest. The only issue in my mind is with monthly emptying, there would almost certainly some amount of umposted "material" in the solids tank. But most people responded that they emptied their solids tank into a plastic garbage bag and disposed of it in a dumpster on shore. Maybe questionable, but that is what most people said they did.

Finally, I have no idea what "diverter valve" is. Our 2005 Airhead has no diverter valve. It separates liquid and solids by its design. I would take a photo but that might just be TMI!

Anyway, we were reassured that we can do the Loop with our Airhead.

_________________

DAYDREAM - CD25 Cruiser
CRABBY LOU - CD16 Angler (sold 2020)
Pat & Patty Anderson, C-Brat #62!
http://daydreamsloop.blogspot.com

Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail Visit poster's website
thataway



Joined: 02 Nov 2003
Posts: 20779
City/Region: Pensacola
State or Province: FL
C-Dory Year: 2007
C-Dory Model: 25 Cruiser
Vessel Name: thataway
Photos: Thataway
PostPosted: Tue Oct 18, 2016 5:09 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Pat, When urine is formed at the pelvis of the kidney (collection system) it is normally sterile. (If not there is going to be a kidney infection). It is contaminated by small amounts of bacteria as it flows into the bladder (more in females), and then out thru the urethra. You skin also has many thousands of bacteria, and I suspose by the same logic we should not swim or wade in any bodies of water (and one of the reasons that swimming pools are chlorinated or have other disinfectants added).

There are rare cases of significant pathogens which can be passed on in the urine. But in the US, these disease are very rare. It is interesting that there was very gross contamination of the Rio waters where at least 5 water sport venues were held. Yet, there were minimal reported illnesses. There the bacterial count, and number of types of pathogens are far greater than would be present by discarding urine into the body of water.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
Marco Flamingo



Joined: 09 Jul 2015
Posts: 1154
City/Region: Seattle
State or Province: WA
C-Dory Year: 2004
C-Dory Model: 16 Cruiser
Vessel Name: Limpet
Photos: Limpet
PostPosted: Tue Oct 18, 2016 5:28 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

My solution, like any solution, will have its advocates and its opponents.

I had to come up with something for staying several weeks on Lake Powell on a CD 16. I first though about how people dispose of other excrement, like baby diapers, dog poop, and even adult diapers. Baby diapers are often thrown in the parking lot or left in shopping carts, but that's actually not the proper method of disposal. One is supposed to remove most of the feces from the disposable diaper, flush that down a toilet, and then fold the used diaper and place it in the trash. That is probably done about as often as leaving them in a parking lot. And does removing most of the feces really accomplish anything?

The same technique is proper etiquette for people picking up dog poop in a plastic bag (reason #26 for not having a dog). Has anybody ever seen anybody squeeze the dog feces out into a toilet before throwing the bag in the trash? Not me.

I have no experience with adult diapers (yet). Actually, I have no experience with baby diapers (no kids, ergo no grand kids) and no experience with dog poop baggies (no pets). So I have never once dumped in to the trash the thousands of poopy diapers or hundreds of poopy baggies that the average American (or Canadian) has tossed.

From an ecological or "green" perspective, I figure that I have banked thousands of what I will call "poop points." I could put into the trash thousands of bags of my own BMs and still not catch up with the average person. So much for the any ecological/public safety/hygiene issues (for me).

My system is simple. It consists of a homemade WAG bag, sort of like this.

https://www.amazon.com/Reliance-Products-Double-Doodie-Toilet/dp/B0024O0W94/ref=pd_lpo_200_bs_img_2?_encoding=UTF8&psc=1&refRID=T26BKCXKRPFCJEHCWHRT

My system uses a 2.5 gallon bucket with an air/water tight gamma lid, a double liner of plastic bags, and "Poo Powder" (Google it). Yes, it gets dumped directly into the trash. About once a week, even when I have two people on board. That is probably less feces going in the trash than having a baby and a dog on board. And, unlike dogs and babies, there is no smell.

Like I said, probably not for everybody.

Mark
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail Visit poster's website AIM Address
C-Green



Joined: 12 Apr 2004
Posts: 310
City/Region: Houghton
State or Province: MI
C-Dory Year: 2002
C-Dory Model: 22 Cruiser
Vessel Name: C-Green
Photos: C-Green
PostPosted: Tue Oct 18, 2016 6:12 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Note that the regulation is an Ontario regulation and does not apply to the rest of Canada as far as I know. I cruised the Canadian shore of Lake Superior a week to 10 days each summer from 2003 to 2011 with a Thetrford porti potti and no issues. Kept the pp in the cockpit with a blanket over it when in a marina, so as to not advertise its use. Only once saw a MNR boat and it was after fishing violations and heading out into the lake from the marina we were docked at. It seems to be a regulation that is administered with benign neglect unless I assume there is a blatant pollution violation and then they would have one more violation to cite besides the pollution.

Jay
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
tomherrick
Guest





PostPosted: Tue Oct 18, 2016 7:26 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Correct, this is an Ontario provincial regulation that supersedes that of the federal government. The gentleman I spoke to at OMECC was somewhat circumspect in his advice regarding how to proceed. Basically, whatever you do, don't throw it overboard. If they can see that you've made provisions onboard to cart the waste to the shore one is unlikely to be shackled and hauled away.
Back to top
Pat Anderson



Joined: 02 Nov 2003
Posts: 8551
City/Region: Birch Bay, WA
State or Province: WA
C-Dory Year: 2005
C-Dory Model: 25 Cruiser
Vessel Name: Daydream
Photos: Daydream and Crabby Lou
PostPosted: Tue Oct 18, 2016 7:33 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Incidentally, Air Head recommends two tablespoons of this product at startup to assist composting. It is an enzymatic drain cleaner (!) and my thought is, we have nothing to lose by giving it a whirl!
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail Visit poster's website
BrentB



Joined: 15 Jul 2006
Posts: 4419
City/Region: Greenwood
State or Province: IN
Photos: BrentB
PostPosted: Tue Oct 18, 2016 8:08 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Bladder urine has its own micobiome. Lab tests detect common uropathogens based on conventional culture media (Blood and MacConkey agar plates) or we look for horses not zebras. However I have a seen a few zebras over the years.
_________________
Brent Barrett
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
AstoriaDave



Joined: 31 Oct 2005
Posts: 994
City/Region: Astoria
State or Province: OR
PostPosted: Tue Oct 18, 2016 8:52 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Much of this discussion focuses on toilet hygiene on freshwater bodies or confined saltwater bays ... and I am impressed with the concern about protecting those waters from human fecal matter. We traveled with an approved MSD on Canadian waters, and disposed of its contents in shoreside toilets ... only to discover later that a few of the shoreline communities, some quite large, do not treat their municipal sewage at all, instead making use of deepwater "straight shot" pipes! Sequence: Us > MSD >toilet > sewer system > deepwater pipe. One wonders about the sanity of this!
_________________
Dave Kruger
Astoria, OR
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Will-C



Joined: 21 Aug 2007
Posts: 2476
City/Region: Temple
State or Province: PA
C-Dory Year: 2008
C-Dory Model: 23 Venture
Vessel Name: Will-C
Photos: Will-C
PostPosted: Wed Oct 19, 2016 8:16 am    Post subject: Composting toilets vs. regulations Reply with quote

In our travels to B.C. this year I could not help but notice the lack of pump out stations up in that area. Given the amount of boats that frequent the area, I would think a lot of waste just gets pumped out into their waters. Pump outs up there were 10 dollars and change. I can imagine how the cheap skates handled that issue. I think if the Canadian government might consider subsidizing by making pump outs free in an effort to keep their waters pristine. It certainly has helped clear up the waters in busy places in this country.
D.D.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   Reply to topic    The C-Brats Forum Index -> Wastewater Systems All times are GMT - 5 Hours
Goto page 1, 2  Next
Page 1 of 2

 
     Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You cannot attach files in this forum
You cannot download files in this forum



Page generation time: 0.0963s (PHP: 85% - SQL: 15%) - SQL queries: 29 - GZIP disabled - Debug on