Dinghy Replacement

LesR · Posted: Tue May 25, 2021 2:18 pm Post subject: Dinghy Replacement

I have an Alaska Series 270TDS dinghy, and identified a leak in one of the seams when assembling it for this week's "shakedown" cruise. As I investigated the leak, the main tube seam separated enough to allow me to stick my hand into the gap.

I called Alaska Series and was told this was not a tricky repair using two-part PVC adhesive. When I mentioned my concerns about possible weakness in the adhesive in other (yet to be determined) locations, he indicated a hesitance for distributing these boats in warmer climates due to the adhesive construction. The dinghy is 10 years old had has spent most of its life in my often very-warm garage. My favorite cruising partner and I are uneasy about making a repair this week, leaving for our Alaska trip next week, and having the confidence needed for this boat.

Unless someone has experience with this type of repair and convinces me that it is a low-risk scenario, I'm inclined to get a new dinghy this week, so that we can test it and the Torqeedo motor I just bought before our planned departure from home late next week.

I realize that given the timing, I may be left with fewer choices. It appears that the local West Marine has their PRU-3 Inflatable in stock (8'4", wood slatted roll-up floor). I don't think this would be my first choice, (would rather have air floor) but given the limited time and our overall limited dinghy usage, this may be a reasonable choice.

Any experience with this or similar WM boats? Any other recommendations?
Thanks any and all input!

Les Rohlf

ssobol · Posted: Tue May 25, 2021 2:32 pm Post subject:

One thing about repairing PVC boats is that the adhesive is sensitive to humidity when curing. Places that repair these boats usually have airconditioned repair bays for gluing and curing.

If you DIY, you need to make sure the humidity is low when you do the gluing.

kaelc · Posted: Tue May 25, 2021 2:35 pm Post subject:

I would go for Zodiac Cadet as it has an inflatable keel and seems reasonably priced. We had our floor repaired on our Alaska series and it is leaking again. https://www.zodiac-nautic.com/en/shop/produits/equipment/tenders/cadet-roll-up/

journey on · Posted: Tue May 25, 2021 2:37 pm Post subject:

If the Alaskan is constructed of PVC (as opposed to hypalon) I understand why the guy who sells them is hesitant to have them used in hot climates. I've seen PVC deteriorate in months in Mexico and the south Pacific. 10 years gives your monies worth.

Look at Defender, they sell most brands and can express them to you. We have an Achilles that has given us 15 years of service, with a few repairs, and is still going strong. Especially in hot weather. The cheap West Marine dinghies are cheap and I doubt if they last very long. We've rode in a couple and they don't impress.

Boris

ssobol · Posted: Tue May 25, 2021 6:24 pm Post subject:

thataway · Posted: Tue May 25, 2021 8:03 pm Post subject:

I have owned the West Marine PRU 2 and 3. The 3 is better. One thing to be aware of is that the "slats" are pretty flimsy. ended up by glassing on both sides, and then painting. They can crack. The floor is not as stable as an air floor. I have an Air floor now--and a much. better boat--plus the air floor will plane, if you put a big enough motor on it. It will go faster with the Torpedo than the PRU will. You could make a light plywood floor to go inside of the PRU 3 and that would be more stable--leaving the slats in place.

I didn't have any seam issues with the PRU series. But I keep the dinghy in my garage when not in use.

I am a little surprised that the Alaska boats are having this issue. My Avon (made for West Marine), is PVC and 20 years old...still looks and functions very well.

I would patch the Alaska and sell it, or keep it--. They are quality boats. There are shops which will professionally pull the seams apart and then redo all of them-- if the fabric is good, then almost a new boat...

LesR · Posted: Tue May 25, 2021 10:50 pm Post subject:

Thanks very much for all your replies.

I'll look for a professional to repair the Alaska Series. It's seen minimal use, and the fabric itself seems to be in excellent shape. For this year's adventure, completing and verifying a thorough fix seems impractical. Bob, I agree these seem like quality boats, and a lightly used one with a quality repair is worth keeping or passing on to someone who will make good use of it.

Defender has a limited supply of air floor dinghies in stock. One that looks reasonable is the Zodiac Wave 310 Aero (https://www.defender.com/product.jsp?id=4409893). I read somewhere that the Aero models are private labeled for Defender. It's a little longer than I need, but appears it will fit on the roof of my 25 with only a slight overhang of the cockpit cover.

Thanks again for the replies - I remain open to any other suggestions and recommendations.

Les

hardee · Posted: Wed May 26, 2021 2:19 am Post subject:

I have a Wolverine, Same as the Alaska by the same producer, just at a different factory so it has a different name - Wolverine. It is 15 years old and I have recently glued a couple of seam leaks in the air floor. Seems to be holding well.

I have carried the 240 for all 15 years, and used it some every year. They are tough, durable and row like a pig, but they float REALLY WELL, and that is why I carry it.

Harvey
SleepyC Moon

Swee Pea · Posted: Wed May 26, 2021 3:31 pm Post subject: Dinghy Repair

Call the people at Offshore Rafting (252) 571-0421, an inflatable boat repair facility second to none. They KNOW repairs. I have had conversations with them, visited them, been to their website and Facebook site, and it is generally true that when pvc boat seams start to give out, usually due to heat, humidity, etc, it is the glue in the seams giving out. It may be repairable, but once one seam starts to deteriorate, so go the rest. It may be salvageable, but you don't want to put good money into bad. If you want a relatively inexpensive dinghy that will last, even though it is PVC, get a Defender Wave. Although pvc (French Zodiac material), all the seams are welded like expensive Zodiac Hypalons, and made in the French Zodiac factory.

John
Swee Pea

LesR · Posted: Fri May 28, 2021 12:12 am Post subject:

John,
Thanks very much for the reference to Offshore Rafting. I will likely consult with them when we return from this summer's trip.

When rolling up and putting away the inflatable yesterday, one of the motor bracket mounts fell off Shocked

, and I noted other components that had begun to separate from the main tubes. I have a Zodiac Wave 10' boat on the way from Defender, which should arrive next Wednesday.

Les

Swee Pea · Posted: Sat Jun 12, 2021 7:56 am Post subject: Inflatable

Did you get the Wave? What do you think of it?
John
Swee Pea

LesR · Posted: Sat Jun 12, 2021 10:33 pm Post subject:

Yes, I got the Wave 310 Aero from Defender. We like it so far after a couple trial runs. I'll update our use of it on the "Intuition to Alaska" thread once we use it more.

localboy · Posted: Tue Jun 25, 2024 4:48 pm Post subject:

Our inexpensive PVC dinghy began coming apart last summer. Lots of delaminating but when the transom started to come apart, I knew it was done. Looked and looked for a suitable replacement. Wanted something under 8’ for weight/handling reasons, air floor and wanted to use our Suzuki 2.5. Saturn no longer makes them. In fact, hardly anyone does. So I looked at Zodiac & Highfield. Ended up buying a close-out Highfield 6’7”, 53 lbs, 550 capacity, 3.5 horse max. Aluminum transom.🤔. Quality seems excellent and it’s easy to handle.